Entrance of a building with a wooden door and staircase, flanked by decorative elements and surrounded by greenery.

Lo
Scudaio

Guest House
Montescudaio, Italien

The road from Cecina winds in switchbacks through vineyards and olive groves, until Montescudaio appears on its hill, a medieval village looking out over the sea and its islands. At the edge of the village, beneath an old pittosporum tree, a heavy iron gate opens onto the oldest wing of a palazzo that looks unassuming from the outside and is, inside, pretty much the opposite.

 

The Location

Montescudaio sits on a hill some eleven kilometres inland from the Tyrrhenian coast. Its neighbours Guardistallo and Casale Marittimo occupy the next hilltops along, all three looking down on the plain of the Cecina. The name goes back to the Latin Mons scutorum, hill of shields. The first settlement grew up around a Benedictine convent founded in 1091 by Count Gherardo della Gherardesca. From the old castle walls you look out to sea and, on clear days, to the islands of the Tuscan archipelago. On the other side, the hills roll inland towards Volterra.

With around two thousand inhabitants, the village is listed among Italy’s most beautiful. It is also small enough that newcomers don’t stay anonymous for long; people greet each other on the piazza and know who has just moved in. Walk through the lanes and you will come across faces without mouths, reproductions of works by the painter Stefano Tonelli from the months when masks covered everyone’s face. Lo Scudaio stands at the edge of the historic centre, behind a heavy wrought-iron gate.

 

 

Backstory

For years, Käte and Ulrich Caspar met the same woman almost every day, in the bar, at the grocer’s, on the piazza. She was tall and slim, with long blond hair and a small dog on her arm that took a dislike to Käte. Only gradually did they learn who she was. Nadia Marchionneschi lived with her ailing mother in the palazzo at the edge of the village, and parts of the house were to be sold at auction. The Caspars bid without ever having seen the rooms inside.

The house had come to her family in the early twentieth century. The lawyer Giulio Marchionneschi, whose ancestors had moved from Piedmont to farm land near Volterra, bought a ruined seventeenth-century stable and built onto it. From the street it looked like a palazzo; inside were barn, oil mill and wine press. By the time the Caspars acquired it in 2017, much of it had begun to crumble.

 

 

Restoration began in 2018, much of it by hand and without a fixed stylistic plan. Ulrich, an architect, worked from whatever each room revealed. Over the same years, the couple’s idea of the house took shape. They wanted a house large enough for guests to withdraw completely and still run into one another, and into the village, whenever they chose. It has since hosted a book presentation from the village’s literary series, Il borgo che legge, and the press launch of Montescudaio’s first film festival. The name is an invention too: Lo Scudaio combines Montescudaio with scuderia, the Italian word for stable – conceived, the owners recall, over a long night in nearby Casale Marittimo.

 

 

Interior & Architecture

Lo Scudaio is divided into two wings. The Scala Antica, the older part, opens up via a stone staircase behind the iron gate: five rooms, each with its own story, some beneath old roof beams, others under the cross vaults of the former stables.

The Scala Grande, once the Marchionneschi family’s residential wing, is reached by a wrought-iron staircase: five further rooms, with historic colour schemes, Art Nouveau ornaments and ceiling paintings, some with sea views.

 

 

Before construction began, the palazzo was cleared and cleaned, leaving its half-ruined interiors ready to become the setting for painter Stefano Tonelli’s three-day-and-three-night exhibition, Impermanenza — impermanence. Tonelli covered the walls with murals created especially for the occasion. The title proved to be remarkably literal: almost all of the work disappeared again during the restoration, with traces surviving in only two rooms.

 

 

The murals vanished after a few weeks, except in two rooms, where they survive to this day. Floors of Venetian terrazzo, frescoes and floor mosaics were carefully uncovered rather than replaced.

 

 

 

A Look Inside

Fifteen rooms accommodate up to twenty-five guests. Ten are divided between the Scala Antica and Scala Grande, five in each wing; another five are tucked beneath the roof in the Sottotetto. The rooms of the Scala Grande are grander, with ceiling paintings and historic colours, some looking out to sea.

Throughout, linen and cotton fabrics in warm, earthy tones, plus underfloor heating. Shared spaces include the Sala Grande with its cross vaults, the Sala Camino with its open fireplace, the Sala Lettura for reading, and a veranda facing the garden.

 

 

Anyone seeking retreat finds a quiet corner at any hour—the house is large enough that you needn’t dodge anyone, and can still have your peace. The shared rooms work the other way round: at breakfast in the Sala Grande or by the fire in the Sala Camino, guests end up talking to each other without anyone arranging it.

 

 

 

Culinary

Breakfast is one of the things worth getting up early for at Lo Scudaio: organic, seasonal, from small local producers—bread, fruit, yoghurt, cheese, cured meats, jam, honey, much of it homemade. Served between half past eight and ten, in the Sala Grande or on the veranda, weather permitting.

The house has no restaurant of its own for the evening, and doesn’t need one: five minutes’ drive away is SaQua by Il Frantoio, listed in the Michelin Guide, chef Simone Acquarelli, modern Tuscan cooking on a terrace looking out over the hills and, on a clear day, the sea. In the village itself, choices range from simple trattorias to wine bars devoted to the local Montescudaio DOC—a wine barely known beyond the region, and interesting for exactly that reason.

 

 

 

Wellness & Relaxation

The Laboratorio, a sunny room facing the garden, hosts the weekly Qi Gong session with Master Renzo Marconi. Groups of up to twenty book the house for seminars and workshops, and the Laboratorio is where they work.

The garden itself, with its pines, olive trees, lime trees and magnolias, offers a different retreat at every turn—some corners shady and cool, others open to the afternoon sun.

 

 

Anyone who doesn’t need a yoga class still finds their moment: on the veranda with a glass of wine, in the Sala Lettura with a book, or simply on a bench under the pines, where the air smells of resin and sea.

 

 

 

Surrounding Area

Montescudaio lends its name to its own DOC appellation, a wine standing in the shadow of its more famous neighbour Bolgheri, further south along the coast—the wine road with the cypresses immortalised by Carducci, where Sassicaia and Ornellaia are made. Anyone wanting to taste for themselves needn’t go far: several estates in the region welcome visitors.

The sea is a quarter of an hour away, at the Blue Flag beach of Cecina. Inland lie the Etruscan hill valleys, with Volterra as the most striking destination—a city of alabaster, an Etruscan museum, and one of Tuscany’s best-preserved medieval skylines. Anyone wanting to go further can reach San Gimignano, Lucca or Siena within one to two hours’ drive. Closer by, and considerably less crowded, are the neighbouring villages of Guardistallo and Casale Marittimo, both with their own character and hardly a coach tour in sight.

 

 

Activities

Anyone wanting to explore the area beyond the house will find a first sorting by interest here.

Wine and Food

  • Tastings with Montescudaio DOC winemakers, many within walking distance or a short drive
  • A trip to the Bolgheri wine road, further south along the coast
  • The Sagra del Vino, held on the first weekend of October since 1968

 

Culture

  • Volterra, the alabaster city with its Etruscan museum
  • San Gimignano, the medieval tower town, about an hour’s drive away
  • Guardistallo and Casale Marittimo, barely visited neighbouring villages

 

 

Active & Outdoors

  • Hiking and cycling through the hills of the Etruscan valleys
  • The Blue Flag beach at Cecina, a quarter of an hour away
  • Stand-up paddling at sea

 

Quiet & Retreat

  • Weekly Qi Gong with Master Renzo Marconi in the Laboratorio
  • Seminars and workshops by arrangement
  • An afternoon in the garden under pines and magnolias

 

 

 

Details

  • 15 rooms: five in the Scala Antica, five in the Scala Grande and five in the Sottotetto; up to 25 guests
  • Shared spaces: Sala Grande, Sala Camino, Sala Lettura, veranda
  • Laboratorio for yoga, Qi Gong and seminars
  • Garden with pines, olives, lime trees, magnolias
  • Breakfast organic and regional, 8.30am to 10am
  • Underfloor heating, air conditioning
  • EV charging nearby
  • Private parking
  • Restaurant SaQua five minutes’ drive away
  • www.loscudaio.com